The Lord of the Rings has a lot to answer for. As much as this trilogy has shaped cinema, whether those who dislike the films and fantasy don’t want to admit, TLOTR were three films to be admired. Changing the way blockbusters are made, stepping up the use of practical and VFX and not to mention the rich storytelling and world of Tolkien, these films have stood the test of time. However, once they had all released, they left a void that studios wanted, needed to fill. The Hobbit was made, but unfortunately three films was too much. Then Amazon decided we needed another prequel, and instead of following the many books Tolkien wrote about Middle Earth, we were gifted The Rings of Power. The show divided fans of TLOTR and the books alike. But the most irritating part of The Rings of Power is the use of The Lord of the Rings name, using like a brand. This was disappointing we; the audience couldn’t just enjoy the show for what it is, a story with new exciting characters. We are forever doomed to have the characters from TLOTR loom over these tales. When it was announced that there was another film on the horizon, this time animation and set in Rohan, there was intrigue and even excitement. But when once again TLOTR was slapped on the title, you could feel fan’s hearts sink. This branding that studios insist on having ruins the feel and tone of the film before anyone has even seen it. We are pre-programmed to expect to love what we are about to see just because of the branding. Something the studios really need to rethink. Leave The Lord of the Rings alone. By all means, create something new but stop branding it incorrectly, especially as War of the Rohirrim has nothing to do with TLOTR.
Set many years before The Hobbit, and years before The Lord of the Rings, we are told about Hera, daughter of king Helm Hammerhand of Rohan. Narrated by none other than the Shield Maiden of Rohan herself, Eowyn, she tells us of a tale about someone who could have very much inspired Eowyn’s actions in TLOTR. When Wulf, a banished son of a disgraced lord of Rohan returns for vengeance, set on killing Helm, Hera and her two brothers, the entire Rohan is threatened. After a brief battle, the people of Edoras retreat to their stronghold, a place very familiar for fans. There they try and out wait their enemies who surround them. After a series of tragedies, Hera is the one who stands up for her people and executes a plan to win back the crown and defeat this villain once and for all.
With very brief mentions of neighbouring Gondor and dig about how they cannot be trusted, along with one quick relevant cameo and a name drop. The War of the Rohirrim thankfully doesn’t fall into the same trap as The Rings of Power. The story and characters are heroic, stoic, and devastating but despite being new additions, they are far from fresh. Acting as stock characters in any other fantasy or historical drama, the story feels more like a Studio Ghibli film, complete with a ‘strong female lead’ who even mentions several times she doesn’t need a man and doesn’t want to get married. While this may seem progressive and what people think feminism is, by now, this feels old hat. Even the entire reason for the war in the first place seems like a very tired trope, with the villain, Wulf wanting revenge for his father’s death, it seems far more obvious he was annoyed Hera rejected him romantically. Thousands die - its war after all - but all because a woman said no to a man. Stripping the narrative to the bone, this is essentially what happens.
Another aspect that lets the film down is the length. A third of the film is set during a siege in Winter whether nothing momentous happens. Apart from a not so mysterious being is killing the enemy one by one. But this section drags out and it’s a shame as the action and momentum the film began with grinds to a halt and tries very hard to pick up the pace at the end but fails to rekindle the magic that could have saved it.
But it is not all cold weather and angry little men, we learn some of Rohan’s history and some mythology about certain creatures. Though the battle scenes feel and look very familiar, one is very much like the Pelennor Fields and the other is literally at Helm’s Deep (spoiler, the stronghold was named after Helm), but they are thrilling to watch, especially without the presence of Elves and the Fellowship. The animation is also the most stunning element of the film. The filmmakers have captured why we all fell in love with Middle Earth and focused in on lands that are (at first) intriguing to explore. But as for further tales of Rohan? If they were to be something completely new then they would be welcomed but of its more of the same, we have certainly reached journeys end.